Geinium
Home › Box, solvent, ions and membranes

Box, solvent, ions and membranes

The periodic box, the water model, the salt and, for membrane proteins, the lipid bilayer and its staged equilibration.

The box

The complex is placed in a periodic box so that it is surrounded by solvent on every side. The shape and the solute-box distance decide how much water the system holds, and with it the speed of the run.

ShapeCharacteristicWhen to use it
"Rhombic dodecahedron" (default)The closest shape to a sphere among periodic boxes; needs the least water for a given distance.Almost always: a globular complex tumbling freely.
"Truncated octahedron"Also close to a sphere, slightly more water than the dodecahedron.When a later tool expects this shape.
"Cubic"Simple to picture, but the most water for the same distance.When a simple box is required, or for a comparison with older work.
"Rectangular (triclinic)"Builder only: a box with the edges of the solute plus the distance.An elongated solute whose orientation is kept by restraints.

"Solute-box distance" (default 1.0 nm; 0.8 to 2.0 nm on Run MD, 0.5 to 5.0 nm on the Builder) is the smallest distance between the solute and the box edge. With the 1.0 nm cut-off, 1.0 nm keeps a solute from interacting with its own periodic image through the cut-off as long as it does not change shape much. Increase it for a flexible protein that may unfold or extend, or for a complex with long termini.

Water

Run MD and the Batch queue use TIP3P water, the model AMBER ff14SB and GAFF2 were parametrised with. The System Builder lists the water models of the chosen force field; with amber14sb these are OPC, OPC3, SPC, SPC/E, TIP3P and TIP4P-Ew. Change the model only for a deliberate comparison: the protein and ligand parameters are balanced against TIP3P.

Ions

SettingDefaultMeaning and when to change it
"Neutralise"onCounter-ions bring the net charge of the system to zero, which PME electrostatics assumes. Leave it on.
"Salt" / "Salt concentration"0.15 mol/L NaCl (0 to 2)Added after neutralisation; 0.15 mol/L is physiological. Set 0 for a comparison with work in pure water, or the buffer concentration of an experiment you want to match.
"Ions" (Builder)NA and CLThe ion names of the force field; SOD and CLA with CHARMM36.

Ions replace randomly chosen water molecules at least 0.6 nm from the solute. The random choice uses the seed 1993, so the same input always gives the same system.

Membrane proteins

A membrane protein in a box of water is not in its native environment: its hydrophobic surface faces water, and loops and helices can move in ways the bilayer would not allow. Geinium therefore checks every protein before the start. A protein with two or more segments whose mean Kyte-Doolittle hydropathy over a 19-residue window is above 1.6 is treated as a membrane protein. If no membrane was chosen, the "Membrane protein" dialog asks for a decision.

The
The "Membrane protein" dialog. Look at the first line, which names the job and the transmembrane segments found, and at the two choices: "Use a membrane (POPC:CHOL 7:3)" is preselected, and "Simulate without a membrane" enables OK only when a reason has been typed.
ChoiceWhat happensWhen to use it
"Use a membrane (POPC:CHOL 7:3)"The job is switched to a membrane system: the protein is embedded in a Lipid21 bilayer and the staged equilibration below is used.Whenever the transmembrane part matters for the question.
"Simulate without a membrane" with "Reason (required)"The protein is simulated in water. The reason is stored in the job and printed in the "Membrane" row of the report.A deliberate choice, such as a study of an extracellular vestibule or a soluble domain, or a fast screen whose limits you accept.

The dialog is asked by Run MD and the Batch queue before the start, and by the System Builder before a build. A report for a membrane protein simulated in water without a stated reason is blocked by the scientific checks of the export.

The example jobs of this documentation, Dicyclomine_4daj and Tricin-7-O-glucoside_4daj, are the M3 muscarinic receptor simulated in water. This was done on purpose to keep the examples small; their reports say so in the "Membrane" row. It is not a recommended setup for a receptor study.

The bilayer

On Run MD and in the Batch defaults the check box "Membrane (POPC:CHOL 7:3)" embeds the protein in a bilayer of POPC and cholesterol in the ratio 7:3, built from the Lipid21 parameters. The System Builder offers the same with more control:

Builder controlDefaultMeaning and when to change it
"Lipid bilayer"offEmbeds the protein in a bilayer. Needs AMBER ff14SB and TIP3P, and switches the temperature from 300 to 310 K.
"Bilayer""POPC : cholesterol 7:3"Or "POPC": a pure POPC bilayer, simpler and faster to equilibrate, for test systems and for proteins studied in pure phosphatidylcholine.
"Lipid margin"1.5 nmLateral distance from the protein to the box edge, filled with lipids. Increase it for a protein whose surrounding lipids you want to analyse.
"Orientation reference"emptyA structure of the same protein already oriented in a membrane (membrane normal along z), for example from a membrane-orientation reference database. Strongly recommended; see below.
"Structural ions"emptyIon positions in the frame of the orientation reference, for ions that belong to the protein structure. They are transferred and restrained. Requires the reference.

The bilayer is cut from pre-built Lipid21 patches. The POPC:cholesterol patch holds 70 POPC and 30 cholesterol per leaflet (7.286 x 7.286 x 8.526 nm, 47,232 atoms); the POPC patch holds 64 POPC per leaflet (32,540 atoms).

Orientation in the membrane

With an orientation reference, the C-alpha atoms of the protein are aligned to those of the reference and superposed, so the protein sits in the bilayer as the reference says. Without one, Geinium fits the hydrophobic belt of the protein to a slab and warns. The fit was within 3.5 degrees and 0.12 nm for a 544-residue transporter, but 20.6 degrees off for a small helix dimer, whose hydrophobic belt is too short to define the tilt well. Use a reference whenever one exists.

Construction checks

The protein keeps a lateral margin of 1.5 nm of lipids, at least 1.5 nm of water beyond the solute and 2.0 nm beyond the head-group planes. Lipids that overlap the protein are removed, the leaflets are balanced to within 5 %, and no water is left in the hydrophobic core. Before the system is accepted, the closest heavy-atom distance, lipid rings pierced by other molecules, the net charge and the leaflet balance are checked; a system that fails is refused rather than simulated.

The System Builder set up for the glycophorin A dimer:
The System Builder set up for the glycophorin A dimer: "Lipid bilayer" ticked, an orientation reference chosen, and the temperature switched to 310 K. Look at the greyed controls (box, minimisation, equilibration, thermostat, barostat): the membrane protocol fixes them.
The built system in the viewer: the glycophorin A dimer in a bilayer of 128 POPC lipids with water and ions, 39,609 atoms. This picture shows pure POPC, not the POPC:cholesterol mixture of Run MD; look at the
The built system in the viewer: the glycophorin A dimer in a bilayer of 128 POPC lipids with water and ions, 39,609 atoms. This picture shows pure POPC, not the POPC:cholesterol mixture of Run MD; look at the "System" card for the counts of protein, water, ion and lipid atoms.

The membrane protocol

A protein freshly embedded in a bilayer has voids around it and lipids that do not yet pack against it. A membrane system therefore replaces the NVT and NPT equilibration of a soluble system with six stages that release restraints step by step. Minimisation runs for 5000 steps. All stages use 310 K, a thermostat time constant of 1.0 ps, and from the third stage on semi-isotropic C-rescale pressure coupling with a time constant of 5.0 ps, so the area and the thickness of the bilayer relax independently.

StageEnsemble and lengthTime stepBackbone / side-chain restraints (kJ/mol/nm2)Lipid head-group heightLipid dihedrals (kJ/mol/rad2)
Equilibration 1NVT, 125 ps1 fs4000 / 200010001000
Equilibration 2NVT, 125 ps1 fs2000 / 1000400400
Equilibration 3NPT, 250 ps1 fs1000 / 500400200
Equilibration 4NPT, 1 ns2 fs500 / 200200200
Equilibration 5NPT, 2 ns2 fs200 / 500100
Equilibration 6NPT, 5 ns2 fs50 / 000

Together these are 8.5 ns per replica. The equilibration lengths, minimisation settings, thermostat and barostat of a soluble job do not apply to a membrane job. With 4 fs chosen, hydrogen-mass repartitioning is used in production only and equilibration keeps its 1 and 2 fs; 1 fs production is not accepted for membranes.

8.5 ns relaxes the protein into the bilayer under restraints; it does not equilibrate the bilayer. A POPC:cholesterol 7:3 bilayer needs 200 ns or more of unrestrained simulation before properties such as area per lipid, thickness or lipid-protein contacts can be analysed, and the patches were not equilibrated for that long beforehand. The production file carries this advice. Either run a long production and exclude its first 200 ns from the analysis window, or restrict the conclusions to properties of the protein and the ligand that converge faster.

Rebuilding a system into a folder that already holds simulation output moves the old output aside to <name>_before_rebuild_<time> instead of overwriting it.