Geinium
Home › Comparing compounds

Comparing compounds

Several jobs in one view and one report: the comparison table, the overlays and the contact map of the compounds.

When several ligands have been simulated on the same receptor, the Results page and the export put them side by side: one table with the headline numbers of every compound, figures that draw all compounds on common axes, a contact map, and a combined report. The example compares dicyclomine and tricin 7-O-glucoside, both bound to the M3 receptor (4DAJ).

Opening several jobs

Any of these opens several jobs together:

The compound selector in the header switches every single-job figure to the chosen compound, and the Comparison group at the top of the navigation holds the figures that show all compounds.

The comparison tables

Dicyclomine_4daj and Tricin-7-O-glucoside_4daj open side by side: the Compounds table, the comparison table and the residues with the highest contact fraction. Look at the last row, Engine: the two jobs were made by versions 1.0.0 and 1.1.0, and their windows differ (0 to 100 ns and 10 to 100 ns). The table states the difference instead of hiding it; recompute the older job before comparing numbers.
Dicyclomine_4daj and Tricin-7-O-glucoside_4daj open side by side: the Compounds table, the comparison table and the residues with the highest contact fraction. Look at the last row, Engine: the two jobs were made by versions 1.0.0 and 1.1.0, and their windows differ (0 to 100 ns and 10 to 100 ns). The table states the difference instead of hiding it; recompute the older job before comparing numbers.

The overview of a batch adds three tables:

TableRowsNotes
CompoundsOne per compound: ligand residue, formula, charge, atoms, production length, replicas, frames.Check that the jobs are comparable before reading any number.
Comparison of the compoundsBackbone RMSD; ligand RMSD after the protein fit; mean Cα RMSF over residues; radius of gyration; protein-ligand hydrogen bonds; buried surface area; binding free energy; Engine when the program versions differ.Mean ± standard deviation over the analysed frames (or between replicas), and for the binding free energy mean ± block standard error. The note names the window of each compound.
Residues with the highest contact fractionThe three residues that interact with each ligand in the largest fraction of frames.A quick check whether the ligands occupy the same sub-pocket.

The same table is written to raw-data/comparison.csv with one row per compound and three more decimals than the report prints; every number of it is checked against the raw data of its compound when the package is written.

Comparison figures

For eight quantities there are two figures each: all compounds in one graph, and one panel per compound on a common y range. The quantities are the protein backbone RMSD, the ligand RMSD after the protein fit, the Cα RMSF, the radius of gyration, the receptor SASA in the complex, the buried surface area, the protein-ligand hydrogen bonds and the binding free energy over time. Two more figures complete the set: the mean binding free energy as bars, and the contact map. Each compound keeps one colour and dash in every figure. The comparison panels draw no window line.

Backbone RMSD of the two compounds in one graph. Dicyclomine_4daj (blue) fluctuates between 0.3 and 0.6 nm, Tricin-7-O-glucoside_4daj (orange) settles near 0.23 nm. Much of the difference comes from the analysis, not the ligand: the Dicyclomine analyses were made before version 1.1.0, when the T4 lysozyme insert was still fitted with the receptor.
Backbone RMSD of the two compounds in one graph. Dicyclomine_4daj (blue) fluctuates between 0.3 and 0.6 nm, Tricin-7-O-glucoside_4daj (orange) settles near 0.23 nm. Much of the difference comes from the analysis, not the ligand: the Dicyclomine analyses were made before version 1.1.0, when the T4 lysozyme insert was still fitted with the receptor.
The same quantity with one panel per compound and a common y axis. Panels are easier to read than an overlay when the curves cross or when there are more than three or four compounds.
The same quantity with one panel per compound and a common y axis. Panels are easier to read than an overlay when the curves cross or when there are more than three or four compounds.
Cα RMSF of both compounds against the residue number. The receptor parts agree in where their peaks are; the insert (1001 to 1161) differs by a factor of four because only the newer analysis excludes it from the fit. Overlay plots are drawn only for compounds with the same receptor.
Cα RMSF of both compounds against the residue number. The receptor parts agree in where their peaks are; the insert (1001 to 1161) differs by a factor of four because only the newer analysis excludes it from the fit. Overlay plots are drawn only for compounds with the same receptor.

The RMSF overlay compares residue by residue, so compounds are overlaid only when their receptors are the same (the same chain identifiers, sequences and residue numbers). Compounds on different receptors get one panel per receptor on a common RMSF scale.

Mean binding free energy of each compound with the block standard error as the error bar: −51.7 kcal/mol for dicyclomine and −44.6 kcal/mol for tricin 7-O-glucoside. The error bars are small because they measure the error of one trajectory, not the spread between replicas.
Mean binding free energy of each compound with the block standard error as the error bar: −51.7 kcal/mol for dicyclomine and −44.6 kcal/mol for tricin 7-O-glucoside. The error bars are small because they measure the error of one trajectory, not the spread between replicas.
The backbone RMSD overlay on the Results page, with the whole Comparison group of the navigation open on the left.
The backbone RMSD overlay on the Results page, with the whole Comparison group of the navigation open on the left.
Contact map: the percentage of frames in which each residue interacts with each ligand. Dicyclomine is held mainly by TYR 148 (95 %), TYR 533 (92 %) and TRP 199 (77 %), tricin 7-O-glucoside by TYR 506 (94 %), LEU 225 (89 %) and SER 151 (76 %): the two ligands share the orthosteric site but lean on different residues. An empty cell means no interaction at all, '<1' less than 1 % of the frames.
Contact map: the percentage of frames in which each residue interacts with each ligand. Dicyclomine is held mainly by TYR 148 (95 %), TYR 533 (92 %) and TRP 199 (77 %), tricin 7-O-glucoside by TYR 506 (94 %), LEU 225 (89 %) and SER 151 (76 %): the two ligands share the orthosteric site but lean on different residues. An empty cell means no interaction at all, "<1" less than 1 % of the frames.

The rows of the contact map are the residues that interact with at least one compound in 20 % or more of the frames (at most 40), in sequence order; the colour and the printed number are the fraction of frames with any interaction, as in the bar under a residue label of the interaction diagram.

The contact map on the Results page. Read across a row to see whether a residue matters to all ligands or to one only, and down a column for the binding pattern of one ligand.
The contact map on the Results page. Read across a row to see whether a residue matters to all ligands or to one only, and down a column for the binding pattern of one ligand.

The combined report and package

The first page of a combined report: the Compounds table, then chapter 1 'Comparison of the compounds' with the comparison table, the contact residues and the first comparison figure. The note under the comparison table names the window of each compound.
The first page of a combined report: the Compounds table, then chapter 1 "Comparison of the compounds" with the comparison table, the contact residues and the first comparison figure. The note under the comparison table names the window of each compound.

Several jobs exported together give one package with one report. Page 1 carries the Compounds table; chapter 1, "Comparison of the compounds", holds the comparison table, the contact residues and all comparison figures; then follows one chapter per compound with exactly the content of a single-job report. The package holds the comparison figures in images/, raw-data/comparison.csv, the manifest, the report, and one folder per compound with its own images, raw data and manifest. The option -compound-reports of the command line adds a separate report to each compound folder. The default package name is comparison_results.

In the application, Export results with several jobs open shows the job list with One combined report checked. When a Batch queue finishes two or more jobs, a combined package of the batch is written next to the job folders automatically (a setting, on by default). See Exporting results.

Fair comparisons