Geinium
Home › Protonation at pH

Protonation at pH

How the charge states of the protein residues and of the ligand are chosen for the pH of the simulation, how to override them, and how well the ligand rules agree with curated data.

The charge states of titratable groups decide which hydrogen bonds and salt bridges a complex can form, and the net charge of the ligand enters every energy that is reported. Geinium sets both for one pH, reports every state that differs from the input, and lets you override any residue.

The pH setting

"pH" in the Preparation section (0 to 14, step 0.1, default 7.4) applies to the protein and the ligand together. Its tooltip reads "Protonation of the protein and the ligand at this pH (model pKa values)". Leave it at 7.4 for a physiological system; change it when the protein works at another pH, such as a lysosomal or gastric enzyme.

Protein residues

Each titratable residue is protonated when the pH is below its model pKa:

GroupModel pKaState below the pKaState above the pKa
Asp3.9ASH (neutral)ASP (charged)
Glu4.3GLH (neutral)GLU (charged)
His6.0HIP (charged)HID or HIE (neutral)
Cys8.3CYS (neutral)CYM (charged)
Tyr10.1neutralstays neutral (see below)
Lys10.5LYS (charged)LYN (neutral)
Arg12.5chargedstays charged (see below)
N-terminus8.0chargedstays charged (see below)
C-terminus3.1stays charged (see below)charged

Between pH 6.0 and 7.99 every residue keeps its standard state, which is why the default pH needs no decision. Cysteines in disulfide bonds are never changed. Deprotonated tyrosine, neutral termini and neutral arginine have no parameters in the AMBER force fields and are not available. A receptor supplied as a ready topology is not changed.

The model values are those of free amino acids. They do not account for the environment of a residue in the folded protein, so a buried or strongly coupled group can be wrong. For such a residue use an override.

Histidine tautomers

A neutral histidine carries its hydrogen on ND1 (HID) or NE2 (HIE). Geinium chooses the tautomer that fits the hydrogen-bond network around the ring. A histidine next to a carboxylate is reported in the log, because a doubly protonated HIP may describe it better.

As a check of the rules, lysozyme gave one HIP at pH 5.0; seven ASH, two GLH and one HIP at pH 3.0; and five LYN at pH 11.

Overriding a residue

WhereHowWhen to use it
Run MD and Batch: Preparation > Advanced > "Residue states"A table of "Residue" (chain:number, for example A:107) and "State" (HID, HIE, HIP, ASP, ASH, GLU, GLH, LYS, LYN, CYS, CYM, CYX). "Add" appends a row, "Remove" deletes the selected one, and "Apply suggested states" fills in the states suggested for metal sites. A state here wins over the pH.A residue whose state is known from experiment or from the literature, such as a catalytic aspartate dyad or a histidine that coordinates a metal.
System Builder: "Protonation overrides"The same in one line, for example A:508=GLH A:32=ASH.The same, when building on the Builder page.
System Builder: "Keep input protonation"Takes the states from the hydrogens of the input instead of the pH rules.An input prepared carefully elsewhere whose hydrogens are to be trusted.
Preparation > Advanced opened on Run MD, with the
Preparation > Advanced opened on Run MD, with the "Residue states" table. Look at the two columns: the residue as chain:number and its state chosen from the list. The summary line of the section counts the states set ("1 residue state(s)").

If the hydrogens of the input imply other states than the ones simulated, a warning names them; nothing is changed silently.

The ligand

"Ligand protonation" decides whether the ligand is protonated by rules or kept as in the file.

ChoiceWhat happensWhen to use it
"At pH" (default)Acids and bases of the ligand get their state at the pH, whatever the input file holds.Most docking output, which often carries the neutral form drawn by a sketcher or the state chosen by the docking program.
"As in the input file"The hydrogens of the file are kept; groups whose state differs at the pH are named in the log.A ligand whose state you have established yourself, for example from a measured pKa.

The rules assign a pKa to each recognised group and compare it with the pH:

GrouppKa usedState at pH 7.4
Carboxylic acid4.2anion
Tetrazole4.9anion
Acyl sulfonamide4.5anion
Thiazolidinedione6.5anion
Phenolsestimated from the substituents (Hammett relation)usually neutral
Amidine, guanidine11.5, 13cation
Aliphatic aminesestimated by group incrementsusually cation
Imidazole7.0neutral
Benzimidazole5.5neutral
Piperazineper nitrogenone nitrogen of the pair protonated

One state is chosen per molecule; tautomers are not enumerated. A group within about one pKa unit of the pH can go either way in reality, and the single state simulated is then a choice, not a certainty. Groups the rules do not cover are left neutral. Each change is written to the log, for example:

N1 (aliphatic amine, estimated pKa 8.7) protonated at pH 7.4: input neutral, simulated +1
Ligand: net charge +1 at pH 7.4 (input 0)

How well the ligand rules agree

On a development set of 362 drug-like molecules with curated literature charge states, the rules gave the literature net charge at pH 7.4 for 353 molecules (97.5 %): 315 of 318 clear cases (99.1 %) and 38 of 44 borderline cases (86.4 %). Two established reference tools scored 77.1 % and 83.7 % on the same set.

The rules were developed on this set, so the figures describe how well the rules reproduce it, not how they perform on unseen molecules. For a ligand with a group near the pH, check the state in the log and override it with "As in the input file" if you know better.

Where the choice is reported