OptiGein Design Docs
Home › Response surface designs

Response surface designs

These designs are for the stage after screening, when you already know which factors matter and you want the shape of the response, not just its direction. They let you fit curvature, find a peak or a valley, and settle on the best combination of settings.

Why you need more than two levels

A two-level design measures each factor at a low and a high setting only. Two points define a straight line, so a two-level design can tell you that a response rises or falls, but it cannot tell you that the response bends. Real processes bend all the time: a response climbs, flattens at an optimum, then falls again. To see that shape you have to test each factor at three or more settings, and you have to fit a model with squared terms. A model with squared terms is a response surface, and the four designs on this page are the ways OptiGein Design builds one.

What a quadratic model buys you. A quadratic model has a term for every factor, every pair of factors, and the square of every factor. The squares are what let the surface curve, which is what lets the optimizer find an interior best point rather than pushing every factor to a corner.

Central composite

The central composite design is the usual first choice for two to ten numeric factors. It is built in three parts, and each part does a job:

Between the corners, the axial points and the centre, each factor ends up at five distinct settings, which is plenty to fit and check a quadratic model.

The Central Composite configuration page with factor, fraction, alpha and centre-point fields
The central composite configuration page. Set the numeric factors, the core fraction, the axial distance and the number of centre points, then name each factor and its low and high levels.

The axial distance, alpha

Alpha is how far out the star points sit, measured in coded units where the corners are at plus or minus one. The value of alpha decides whether those runs stay inside the factor ranges you typed or reach beyond them. The configuration page offers three choices.

ChoiceAxial distanceWhat it means physically
Rotatable The fourth root of the number of factorial points, about 1.41 for two factors. Prediction is equally precise in every direction at a given distance from the centre. The star points fall outside the low-to-high range you set, so each factor is run a little beyond its stated limits.
Spherical The square root of the number of factors. Every non-centre run sits on one sphere around the centre point. The star points again reach outside your ranges.
Face-centered (α = 1) Exactly one. The star points land on the faces of the cube, at the low or high level itself. No run ever leaves the ranges you set. Choose this when a setting past your limits is impossible, unsafe or too expensive to try.
When a factor cannot go beyond its range. If a factor is already at a hard limit at its high level, a purity that cannot exceed a ceiling or a pump at its maximum speed, use the face-centred choice. Rotatable and spherical both ask for runs outside the range, which you would not be able to perform.

The worked example in this documentation is a face-centred central composite on two numeric factors, A: HPMC E15 from 2 to 4 % w/v and B: Glycerol Ester from 0.5 to 1.5 % w/v. It has 13 runs: four factorial corners, four axial points and five centre replicates. Because it is face-centred, every run stays inside 2 to 4 % w/v for HPMC and 0.5 to 1.5 % w/v for the ester, which is why you never see an out-of-range value on the run sheet.

The Core fraction field only matters once you have enough factors that a full factorial core would be wasteful. With many factors you can pick a fraction of the core, which trims the corner runs while keeping the axial and centre runs intact. With two or three factors the core is simply full.

Box-Behnken

Box-Behnken is a leaner three-level design for three to five numeric factors. Instead of corners and star points, its runs sit at the midpoints of the edges of the design cube, with the remaining factors held at their centre. Each numeric factor takes just three settings: low, middle and high.

The useful property is that no single run puts every factor at an extreme at the same time. Every run has at most two factors at a limit while the rest sit in the middle. If your corner combinations are the risky ones, all factors maxed together, a Box-Behnken design avoids them entirely. It also costs fewer runs than a full three-level factorial would.

The Box-Behnken configuration page for three numeric factors
The Box-Behnken configuration page. It is available for three to five numeric factors and starts with five centre points.

The number of edge runs grows with the number of factors: each pair of factors contributes four runs, so the total is four times the number of factor pairs. That works out to twelve runs for three factors, twenty-four for four and forty for five. On top of that, the design starts with five centre replicates by default, so a three-factor Box-Behnken is seventeen runs. You can change the centre count on the configuration page.

Central composite or Box-Behnken? Both fit the same quadratic model. Reach for central composite when you can run settings a little past your limits and want the extra corner and star coverage. Reach for Box-Behnken when three levels per factor is enough and you want to keep every run away from the all-extremes corners.

Optimal (Custom)

The two designs above have a fixed geometry. An optimal design does not: you tell the software what model you intend to fit and how many runs you can afford, and it chooses the runs for you. This is the design to use when your run budget is set in advance, when you mix numeric and categoric factors, or when the standard shapes do not fit your constraints.

On the configuration page you set the numeric factors, any two-level categoric factors, the model to estimate (main effects, two-factor interactions or quadratic) and the number of runs. Leave the run count on Auto and the software allocates the number of terms in your model plus ten, which leaves room to test for lack of fit and to estimate error. A Fedorov exchange algorithm then searches for the set of runs that measures your chosen model most precisely, swapping candidate runs in and out until the information it gathers stops improving.

The Optimal (Custom) configuration page with a model and run-count selector
An optimal response surface design. State the model and the run budget, and the exchange algorithm assembles the run list.
Give the model enough runs. A quadratic model needs at least as many runs as it has terms just to be estimable, and more than that to be checked. If you ask for fewer runs than the model needs, the configuration page tells you the minimum. Add a few beyond that minimum so you can still test the fit.

Definitive screening

A definitive screening design, or DSD, sits between screening and response surface work. It is built for four to twenty numeric factors, each set at three evenly spaced levels, with room for up to four two-level categoric factors alongside them. Its appeal is how much it separates in very few runs, a little over twice the number of factors.

Two properties make it worth knowing. First, the main effects stay clear of the two-factor interactions, so a large main effect is never an interaction in disguise. Second, because every numeric factor runs at three levels, pure curvature is already visible, meaning you can see whether a factor bends the response before you commit to a full quadratic design. If only a few factors turn out to matter, a DSD often carries you far enough to model them without a second experiment.

The Definitive Screening configuration page for numeric factors
A definitive screening design. Main effects stay clear of two-factor interactions and curvature shows up, all in a compact run sheet.

What to read next