GeinDFT
Home › Electrostatic potential surfaces

Electrostatic potential surfaces

The molecular electrostatic potential mapped on the density surface: how it is computed, what the colours mean, and what the extrema are good for.

The electrostatic potential at a point is the energy a unit positive charge would have there, from the nuclei and the electrons together. Mapped onto the surface of the molecule it shows where an approaching electrophile or nucleophile is attracted, which is why it is the most used picture in the whole of applied quantum chemistry.

An electrostatic potential surface in the viewer. The carbonyl and hydroxyl oxygens are red, the acidic hydrogen is the blue maximum, and the aromatic ring is close to neutral. The scale and the two extrema are shown with the surface.
An electrostatic potential surface in the viewer. The carbonyl and hydroxyl oxygens are red, the acidic hydrogen is the blue maximum, and the aromatic ring is close to neutral. The scale and the two extrema are shown with the surface.

How GeinDFT computes it

StepWhat is doneWhy it matters
The surfaceThe isosurface of the electron density at 0.001 electrons per cubic bohr.This is the standard definition of a molecular surface in this context, and it corresponds roughly to the van der Waals contact surface.
The potentialEvaluated analytically at every vertex of the mesh, not interpolated from a grid.The potential varies sharply near the nuclei, so interpolation introduces error exactly where the surface is most interesting.
The statisticsThe most positive and most negative values, the averages over the positive and negative regions, and the surface area.These numbers are the quantitative part. They can be compared between molecules in a way that a picture cannot.

Reading the colours

ColourMeaningChemistry
RedNegative potentialLone pairs, carbonyl and hydroxyl oxygens, pi systems of electron-rich rings. Where an electrophile or a hydrogen-bond donor is attracted.
GreenNear zeroSaturated carbon frameworks and most carbon-bound hydrogens.
BluePositive potentialAcidic hydrogens, metal centres, the sigma hole on a heavy halogen. Where a nucleophile or a hydrogen-bond acceptor is attracted.
The colour scale is arbitrary unless its range is stated. Two pictures with different ranges cannot be compared by eye, however similar they look. Keep Symmetric about zero on, and fix the same range on both when comparing molecules.

The extrema

The labelled points are the surface minimum and maximum, usually written VS,min and VS,max. They are the single most useful numbers on the surface: the minimum ranks hydrogen-bond acceptors and the maximum ranks donors, and both can be compared across a series computed the same way.

Extrema labelled. Each label is anchored to its point and moves with the view.
Extrema labelled. Each label is anchored to its point and moves with the view.
The same surface with the annotations off, for a figure where the numbers are given in the caption or the text instead.
The same surface with the annotations off, for a figure where the numbers are given in the caption or the text instead.

The labels stay attached to their points as the molecule is rotated, and a point that passes behind the surface is drawn hollow rather than left floating over the front of the picture.

The same molecule rotated. The annotations have followed their points rather than staying where they were drawn.
The same molecule rotated. The annotations have followed their points rather than staying where they were drawn.
The surface in the window with both annotations switched off, which is what to do when the numbers are given in the text instead.
The surface in the window with both annotations switched off, which is what to do when the numbers are given in the text instead.

The same surface as a publication figure

The figures below came from the same calculations, exported through the figure renderer rather than captured from the window. The colour bar, the extrema labels and the caption are part of the image, so the figure explains itself wherever it is reproduced.

Water. The lone pairs on oxygen are the red minimum and the two hydrogens are the blue maximum, which is the textbook picture of a hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor in one molecule.
Water. The lone pairs on oxygen are the red minimum and the two hydrogens are the blue maximum, which is the textbook picture of a hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor in one molecule.
Caffeine. Both carbonyl oxygens accept; with no acidic hydrogen the maximum is modest and spread over the methyl groups.
Caffeine. Both carbonyl oxygens accept; with no acidic hydrogen the maximum is modest and spread over the methyl groups.
Aspirin at single-column width and 300 dots per inch.
Aspirin at single-column width and 300 dots per inch.
The same molecule with every local extremum labelled rather than only the two global ones, which is useful when ranking several sites on one molecule.
The same molecule with every local extremum labelled rather than only the two global ones, which is useful when ranking several sites on one molecule.

Typical values

MoleculeVS,minVS,maxReading
Water-36 kcal/mol+43 kcal/molA strong acceptor at the oxygen lone pairs and a strong donor at the hydrogens.
Aspirin-52 kcal/mol+61 kcal/molThe carboxylic acid dominates both ends of the scale.
Caffeine-40 kcal/mol+30 kcal/molCarbonyl oxygens accept; no acidic hydrogen, so the maximum is modest.
Those numbers come from calculations at B3LYP with a double or triple zeta basis set. Surface potentials depend on the method and basis set, so a series to be compared must be computed consistently.