GeinDFT
Home › Charges and reactivity

Charges and reactivity

The four charge schemes, when each is appropriate, and the descriptors derived from the frontier orbitals.

Four schemes, four answers

An atomic charge is not an observable: it depends on how the electron density is divided between atoms, and there is more than one defensible way to divide it. GeinDFT computes four, and they will not agree. The water molecule below is the clearest possible case.

SchemeOxygenEach hydrogenWhat it is good for
Mulliken-0.294+0.147Trends within one molecule at one basis set. Strongly basis-set dependent.
Loewdin-0.150+0.075The same idea, better behaved, still basis-set dependent.
Hirshfeld-0.309+0.155Comparing the same atom across different molecules. Small, stable values.
CHELPG-0.707+0.353Anything electrostatic: force-field parameters, or reasoning about how a molecule interacts at a distance.

The numbers are from water at B3LYP with a triple-zeta basis. They differ by a factor of more than four between schemes, which is the point: quote the scheme with the number, and never compare a charge from one scheme with a charge from another.

Charges in the picture

Charge labels in the viewer. Every atom carries its computed charge, which makes the polarity of a functional group immediately visible.
Charge labels in the viewer. Every atom carries its computed charge, which makes the polarity of a functional group immediately visible.

Analyze > Charge Labels (Q) labels the atoms. View > Colour by Charge colours them instead, with a diverging scale that puts neutral in the middle, which reads better for a large molecule.

Bond orders

Mayer bond orders come from the density matrix rather than from the drawn connectivity. A value near one, two or three is a single, double or triple bond; a value near one and a half across a ring is the delocalisation you would expect in an aromatic system. They are the honest way to ask what the calculation thinks the bonding is, rather than what the input file asserted.

Reactivity descriptors

DescriptorDefinition usedReading it
Ionisation potentialMinus the HOMO energyHow readily the molecule gives up an electron.
Electron affinityMinus the LUMO energyHow readily it accepts one.
Chemical hardnessHalf the HOMO to LUMO gapResistance to change in electron number. Large gap, hard molecule.
ElectronegativityMinus the average of the two frontier energiesThe tendency to attract electrons overall.
Electrophilicity indexFrom electronegativity and hardnessA single number for how electrophilic a molecule is, useful for ranking a series.
These descriptors rest on the frontier orbital energies, so they inherit their limitations. They are useful for ranking a series of related molecules computed the same way, and misleading when compared across methods or basis sets.

Fukui functions

Fukui functions answer where, not merely how much: they show which atoms carry the density that responds when an electron is added or removed, and therefore where a nucleophile or an electrophile will attack. They need the cation and the anion as well as the neutral molecule, so they cost two extra calculations and are off by default.